Reading Notes
Beattie..
#Week 2
James Beattie
On pg. 130 - I appreciated the way the author set up his argument he found an error with Hume's statements when he spoke about slavery. He didn't wait and just keep this knowledge to himself but was enraged and wrote an essay on truth.
Also on pg.130 - This introduction for James Beattie is beautifully outline of the just of his argument in his letter. And I am also excited because I caught an error also in Hume's comments in my last notes. Mr. Beattie says "such assertions of inferiority and superiority necessarily legitimate the practice of slavery."This part of his argument was most moving because Hume who even had not much experience with African people just made the assumptions that his was superior. Well, in the moment physically since we were slaves they were on top but not proven mentally.
Also on pg.130 - This introduction for James Beattie is beautifully outline of the just of his argument in his letter. And I am also excited because I caught an error also in Hume's comments in my last notes. Mr. Beattie says "such assertions of inferiority and superiority necessarily legitimate the practice of slavery."This part of his argument was most moving because Hume who even had not much experience with African people just made the assumptions that his was superior. Well, in the moment physically since we were slaves they were on top but not proven mentally.
Mary Wollstonecraft
On pg.133 - It was powerful how Mary stepped out with courage with The Vindication of Men in 1791. Being a women in her time challenging mens theory's showing that women could also be enlightened. But one year after she made her presence really know in the community around her.
Also on pg.130-133 - It shows the courage that Marry Wollstonecraft reviled by doing a twist to her letter in the previous year to make a The Vindication of Women speaking up for her sex and basically starting a strong female stance. Arguing the basses of how marriage was demeaning as prostitution and left most women in the same place as slaves. No education or even laws that make men and women equal.
A quote from pg. 134- "..that till the manners of the times are changed, and formed more reasonable principals, it may be impossible to convince them that the illegitimate power, which they obtain, by disregarding themselves, is a curse, and that they must return to nature and equality, if they wish to secure the placid satisfaction that unsophisticated affections impart." This quote shows how Mary believes the walk that women have in society is unfair and must be changed so that both sex were equal.
De La Cruz Poems
On pg. 262 - I enjoyed Poem 164 the most because of the imagery it gave when reading it. Also how it goes into detail of love in heartbreak in such of a quick poem where as on Poem 92 went on way longer poem outline to share their poem.
On pg. 263- The poem was almost dedicated to women and showing how only a weak man would always throw blame on his women. Where instead the man is the stubborn figure that needs to be more open and less of a dictatorship.
An interesting quote on pg. 264 - " Or which more greatly must be faulted, though either may commit a wrong: she who sins for need of payment, or he who pays for his enjoyment? Why then are you so alarmed by the fault that is your own? Wish women to be what you make them, or make them what you wish they were." This quote shows the equal wrong between men and women and how women are not to blame the stubborn man mostly is and just also shows when it say make them what you wish they were just shows how much men in those times had over women. No ways being equal at all.